Contribution, not percentage
The instinct is to judge dishes by food cost percentage, and it is the wrong instinct. A dish at 40% food cost selling for KES 900 contributes KES 540 in cash. A dish at 25% selling for KES 300 contributes KES 225. The second has the prettier percentage and the first pays the rent.
Contribution is the selling price minus what the ingredients cost. It is the cash each plate leaves behind to cover everything that is not food: wages, rent, power, gas, the loan. Percentages are useful for spotting drift over time; shillings are what you bank.
With contribution for every dish and a count of how often each one sells, the menu sorts itself into four groups. High popularity and high contribution are your stars, and the only job there is not to break them. High popularity and low contribution is the dangerous corner, because volume multiplies a thin margin into a real loss and popularity makes anyone reluctant to touch it.
Low popularity and high contribution are usually a visibility problem rather than a quality one: the dish is fine and nobody sees it. Low popularity and low contribution is the group to cut, and cutting is worth more than it looks, because each line carries stock, prep time and waste risk behind it.
None of this works without accurate recipe costs, which is why restaurant cost control comes first. Costing a dish from the recipe card rather than from what is actually plated produces a tidy analysis of a fictional menu.
Want to see it running in your own business first?
Sign UpWorking through the menu
A half-day exercise, worth repeating when prices move.
- 1
Pull a sales count by dish
Three months if you can, one month at minimum. If the till does not break down by item, a tally sheet for four weeks will do and is worth the effort once.
- 2
Cost each dish from the plate
Weigh what actually goes out, not what the card says. The menu pricing calculator will handle the arithmetic once you have the weights and current prices.
- 3
Work out contribution per dish
Selling price minus ingredient cost. Keep it in shillings. Resist the urge to convert back to a percentage, which is what pulls attention back to the wrong column.
- 4
Plot popularity against contribution
Two columns and a sort is enough; nobody needs a chart. Above and below the average on each gives you the four groups.
- 5
Act differently on each group
Protect the stars and do not quietly shrink them. For popular low earners, cut the ingredient cost, adjust the portion or raise the price a little. Promote the hidden earners by moving them up the menu or letting staff recommend them. Cut the rest.
- 6
Count what cutting saves
Each removed line is stock you no longer hold, prep you no longer do and waste you no longer risk. That saving rarely appears in the analysis and is often the biggest part of it.
- 7
Re-run it when prices move
Kenyan ingredient prices move enough that a dish can drift from star to problem without anybody changing anything. Twice a year is a reasonable rhythm.
Where menu decisions go wrong
Judging by food cost percentage
It flatters cheap dishes and punishes expensive ones, regardless of what each actually contributes. Sort by shillings.
Protecting a popular loss-maker because it is popular
Popularity is exactly what makes it expensive. Fix the cost or the price; the dish can usually survive a modest change without losing its audience.
Cutting dishes staff rely on
A low-selling item may be the one thing a regular group comes for, or the only vegetarian option. Check before removing, because the sales count does not show you who stops coming.
Raising every price at once
Customers notice an across-the-board rise far more than a change on two or three items. Aim at the dishes the analysis names.
Never cutting anything
A menu only grows if nothing comes off, and a long menu is paid for in stock, prep and waste by every service, whether or not those dishes sell.
Analysing once
Prices move, suppliers change and portions drift. A single analysis ages quickly and stops matching the kitchen it was built from.
A Kisumu restaurant and its most popular dish
A restaurant in Kisumu costed its menu properly for the first time and found that its best-selling dish, a fish plate everybody knew it for, had the lowest contribution of any main. The fish had become more expensive over two years and the price had not moved, because the dish was the restaurant’s reputation.
Dropping it was not an option. Instead they changed the accompaniment to something cheaper that suited it just as well, adjusted the fish portion by a small amount that nobody mentioned, and raised the price modestly. Contribution roughly doubled and sales did not visibly move.
The same exercise found two starters that sold rarely and contributed well. Moving them to the top of the page and asking staff to mention them lifted both without any change to the food.
Four dishes came off entirely. The owner’s view afterwards was that the removals saved more than the price changes earned, because the cold room stopped holding six things that existed for a handful of orders a week.
In a busy kitchen, unrecorded orders, comped meals and stock leaving the back door quietly eat the margin you worked all service to earn.
Veira ties every order to the bill and the stockroom, so covers, voids and portions all reconcile at close.
Keeping the analysis current
The hard part of menu management is not the thinking; it is having the sales count by dish and the current recipe cost in the same place at the same time. Done by hand, it is a half-day that gets repeated once and then quietly never again.
Veira is the till, so the sales count by item is already there, and recipes held against menu items mean ingredient price changes flow into dish costs rather than waiting for somebody to redo the arithmetic. That turns a twice-yearly project into something you can look at whenever a supplier price moves: Veira for restaurants.
If you are still choosing a system, the restaurant POS comparison covers what to check before you commit.
Frequently asked questions
What is menu engineering?
Should I use food cost percentage or contribution margin?
How many dishes should a restaurant menu have?
How often should I re-cost the menu?
What do I do about a popular dish that barely earns anything?
Do I need a POS to do this?
Menu management finds money that is already on your menu rather than asking for more customers. Cost from the plate, sort by contribution in shillings, and act differently on each of the four groups. When keeping it current is the obstacle, see how Veira holds recipes against menu items.
Need help, or want to talk it through first? Chat with us on WhatsApp